Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Satoru Inoue's avatar

Personally, what matters is commitment, not loyalty. You commit to a principle, or to a problem, and your actions follow. You need sustained effort to do anything difficult, so you need commitment in order to do real things. Commitment is also how you show others that you mean what you're saying.

You might like Jonathan Haidt's "The Righteous Mind". He tried to come up with different moral principles that people responded to, and "loyalty" was one of the basic principles that were more valued by (American) conservatives than liberals. Liberals tended to focus on "harm/care", where you mainly worried about whether people are harmed or helped by something.

Eric Garneau's avatar

This was a rich post, man! A lot I want to respond to here. I've been thinking about loyalty a lot lately too, and I agree with you that I don't really value it. I didn't articulate why as well as you did, but I'm in agreement with you -- loyalty is often asked to stand as a virtue in places where other virtues aren't present. Nuts to that.

That How Pac Man Eats book looks awesome -- very much my style.

And, I loved your post about playfulness in games, and how it acts as a teacher. You should write a book about this stuff! Haha

No posts

Ready for more?